PHIL 2011 ARISTOTLE

DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY

SCHOOL OF HUMANITIES

THE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG

SEMESTER II 2009-10

 

Lecturer:       Dr Alexandra Cook

                         Room MB 308

                         Ph: 2219-4335

                         Email: cookga@hku.hk

 

Lecture info: Tuesdays 10:40-12:30 p.m., MB 142

 

Tutorials:      REQUIRED essay tutorials on 20 April; we shall schedule additional ones if there is sufficient demand, and students are prepared to attend.

 

Mobile phones: should be OFF during lectures and tutorials.

 

Course Summary:

 

The influence of Aristotle down through the centuries has been enormous¡Xhe contributed to virtually every field of inquiry: logic, biology, physics, politics, and ethics.  In this course we focus on his political and social thought in both its theoretical and empirical aspects.  We examine such key categories of Aristotelian thought such as virtue, happiness, the polis, justice, nature, final ends, education and the Good for man.  

 

Readings:

 

The principal texts for this course are in Aristotle¡¦s The Politics and The Constitution of Athens, available from the HKU bookstore, Main Library Reserves and the Dept. library (see Ms. Loletta Li).  I shall provide some secondary readings on a separate list to provide background knowledge, but these readings should not form the basis for essays or other assignments.  The primary sources by Aristotle are the main focus of the course. 

 

Course Texts:

 

Aristotle, The Politics and The Constitution of Athens, ed. S. Everson (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1996).

 

Other texts referred to in the course plan are available for photocopying in the dept office.  Some of these may also be made available online as pdfs, subject to copyright rules.

 

On reserve in the Main Library:

 

Aristotle, Politics

Books on reading list

 

CLASS FORMAT:

 

The class meets for two hours once a week.  The format comprises some combination of comments by the lecturer, short presentations by students and discussion.

 

ASSESSMENT (THREE components):

 

1. Test (30%): 23 March

 

2. Participation (25%):                             

 

(1) one discussion question/comment on the reading posted at least twenty-four (24) hours in advance of class (a sign-up sheet will be circulated in lecture).

 

(2) participation: in lecture + required essay revision tutorials on 20 April (failure to participate WILL affect your grade).

 

(3) at least ONE well thought-out response to the question/comment for the day on the course Google group (you will need a Google identity).

 

3. Essay (45%): due 7 May, not to exceed 2000 words.

 

The goal of the essay is to give students the opportunity to explore a topic in depth, and formulate a careful argument.  Essays should be coherent, succinct, use proper grammar, display independent thought, AND reference Aristotle¡¦s writings as evidence.  Circulation of essay drafts invites comments from a wider audience for constructive feedback.

 

Course web page:

 

http://www3.hku.hk/philodep/wiki/pmwiki.php?n=Main.Courses

. 

Academic honesty:

 

Unacknowledged use of others¡¦ work constitutes plagiarism.  There are serious penalties for this academic offense.  Reference your work correctly.  See the following link for guidelines on proper referencing: http://www3.hku.hk/philodep/wiki/pmwiki.php?n=Main.Citation.  See ¡¥What is Plagiarism?¡¦ at www.hku.hku/plagiarism for a full discussion of plagiarism.

 

Penalty for late submissions: 5% of original mark per late day, including weekends.

 

COURSE PLAN:

 

19 January: Course Introduction

 

Politics, Book I: The household and the polis

 

26 January: Politics, ¡¥Principal Events¡¦ (p. xxxix), pp. 11-19, Polis, Slavery

Recommended: Selections from T. Wiedemann, Greek and Roman Slavery

 

2 February: Politics, pp. 18-30, Sexual Hierarchy, Property

 

Politics, Book II: Actual and Ideal Constitutions

 

9 February: Sparta, model for Plato

Plato, Republic, 416d-424a, 457c-466d (pdf)

Xenophon, Constitution of the Lacedaemonians (pdf)

 

16 February: Chinese New Year

 

23 February: Sparta: anti-model for Aristotle: Politics, pp. 30-46, 49-59

 

2 March: Mid-term reading break

 

9 March: Citizenship: Politics, pp. 61-69, Constitution of Athens, pp. 211-63, om I. Arnaoutouglou, Ancient Greek Laws: A Sourcebook, pp.17-19, epigamia (pdf)

 

Types of constitutions and their ends: Politics, pp. 71-99, 106-119

 

16 March: HKU Foundation Day¡Xno class

 

19 March: elective tutorial¡Xtime and place tba: discuss test questions and formats

 

23 March: mid-term test

 

Politics, Book VII: Political Ideals

 

30 March: Politics, pp. 166-186; Recommended: ¡§Airs, Waters, Places,¡¨ in Hippocratic Writings (pdf)

 

6 April: no class¡Xpublic holiday

13 April: Politics, pp. 186-199, Principles of education; pp.199-207, Music education, musical instruments and harmoniai; Recommended: W.D. Anderson, Music and Musicians in Ancient Greece, ch. 5 (pdf)

 

20 April: Essay revision tutorials: details tba

 

7 May: essays due