Philosophy 2420, 2008.
Short Essay ASSIGNMENT 3
TOPIC:
In this paper I want you to do some research on the following topic:
In what senses is the Zhongyong not a Daoist text? What are the main differences?
Beside laying out the differences, think of these questions: How would the Taoists criticize the Confucian metaphysics? How would the Confucians criticize the Taoist metaphysics? Which view is in your opinion more convincing and why? We will have a class debate in our next class.
GUIDELINES:
1. The paper should be like an outline of a big paper, with key points, laid out clearly. It should be around 2-3 pages, typewritten, double‑spaced.
2. Don't try to discuss everything. Focus on the most essential.
3. Express yourself as clearly as possible in a coherent and organized manner. Do not throw in words or expression that you yourself don’t understand.
4. Avoid plagiarism. When you cite or paraphrase some sources, acknowledge them and identify the sources very specifically in footnotes or endnotes.
5. Your paper will be evaluated primarily on its understanding of the philosophies involved. Other relevant factors will be its logical organization, clarity of thought, and the depth of your analysis and insights.
DUE DATE: Tuesday, March 25.
Style for
References
References of quotes should appear at the end of each quote, in
parenthesis, with the author’s last name, the year of the publication (when the
paper quotes more than one publications from the same author), and page number.
For example “The quote from Graham” (Graham, 1989, 112). When the quote runs on
in the text, as it is shown above, the last punctuation should be placed after
the reference. When the quote is three lines or longer (exceeds 30 words), it
should be extracted and indented, as is shown below, and the last punctuation
should appear at the end of the quote.
This is extract paragraph style for quotations that are longer than 30 words (shorter quotes should run on in the text). It will look like this. Notice the font is one size smaller than the regular text, and is indented by 0.5 inch from both sides. (Author, year, page number)
When you paraphrase or summarize a text authored by someone, you should
not use quotation marks around the content, but still give bibliographic
information of the text which you paraphrase. For example:
Heaven and human are in a special kind of part-whole relation. Hall and
At the end of the paper you should have a list of bibliographical
references that are actually quoted or paraphrased in the paper (leave out the
ones that you consulted but did not quote or use in your article. List the name
of the author(s), the year of publication, the title of the article or the
book, the publisher, etc. In the case of a web page, indicate the date you
accessed it as well, since web pages may change over the time. Pay attention to
the details of the style in the following examples (such as the use of “hanging
paragraph”) and notice the differences between a journal article and a book:
REFERENCES
Chan, Wing-tsit. 1955. “The Evolution of the
Confucian Concept of Ren.” Philosophy
of East and West, 4, 295-315.
Graham, A. C. 1985. “ ‘Being’ in Classical Chinese,” in Verhaar
(1967), 1-39.
——————. 1989. Disputers of the Tao: Philosophical
Argument in Early
Cheng, Chung-ying 1971. “Chinese Philosophy:
A Characterization.” Inquiry, 14, 95-119.
Hall, David L. and
Verhaar, John
W. M. (ed.) 1967ff. The Verb “Be” and Its Synonyms. Foundations of Language,
Supplementary Series.
Eric Roth. “Forrest Gump,” screenplay based on a novel by Winston Groom. http://www.weeklyscript.com/Forrest%20Gump.txt. Accessed 09/02/2006.